The 10 Best Peanut Butter Dog Treats
Jump to the list
Greenies Pill Pockets Canine Real Peanut Butter Flavor Dog Treats, Capsule Size, 60 count
$17.98Chewy Price
($0.30/ea)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.6/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.4/5
GreatTaste
4.5/5
GreatTexture
4.5/5
GreatPros
- Easy to Use: Convenient and stress-free way to give medication to dogs.
- Delicious Flavor: Dogs love the taste and texture of the pill pockets.
- Effective Hiding: Soft and pliable texture makes it easy to hide pills and capsules.
- Variety of Flavors: Available in different flavors, including peanut butter, chicken, and hickory smoke.
- Reduces Stress: Makes giving medication a breeze, reducing stress for both dogs and pet parents.
Cons
- Texture Issues: Some dogs may not like the texture or find it too crumbly.
- Expensive: Some pet parents find the product to be pricey compared to other options.
Zuke's Mini Naturals Peanut Butter & Oats Recipe Adult Soft & Tender Training Dog Treats, 1-lb bag
$16.98Chewy Price
($16.98/lb)
Promo, Save 15% with code EOSS15
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.7/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.7/5
ExcellentTaste
4.6/5
ExcellentTexture
4.6/5
ExcellentPros
- Effective Training Treats: Highly effective as training treats, encouraging good behavior and motivating dogs to learn.
- Healthy Ingredients: Made with natural, healthy ingredients, making pet parents feel good about rewarding their dogs.
- Soft and Easy to Eat: Soft and tender texture, easy to eat and digest, perfect for small breeds, puppies, and dogs with dental issues.
- Peanut Butter Flavor: Peanut butter flavor is a hit with many dogs, making them a great reward for desired actions.
Cons
- Texture Issues: Some pet parents reported receiving stale or hard treats, which may be a manufacturing or shipping issue.
- Messy to Handle: Some pet parents mentioned that the treats can be sticky or crumbly, making them messy to handle.
Bil-Jac Gooberlicious Peanut Butter Flavor Soft Dog Treats, 10-oz bag
$6.99Chewy Price
($0.70/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.8/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.8/5
ExcellentTaste
4.8/5
ExcellentTexture
4.7/5
ExcellentPros
- Soft and Easy to Chew: Perfect for small dogs, seniors, and dogs with dental issues.
- Delicious Peanut Butter Flavor: Dogs love the taste and smell of these treats.
- Suitable for Sensitive Stomachs: Good for dogs with sensitive stomachs and digestive issues.
- Highly Effective Training Rewards: Dogs respond well to these treats, making training a breeze for pet parents.
Cons
- Some Dogs Don't Like the Taste: A few dogs may not enjoy the peanut butter flavor.
- Expensive Compared to Others: These treats may be pricier than similar products.
- Quality Control Issues: Some pet parents have reported receiving bags that arrive stale or broken into crumbs.
Bocce's Bakery Milk n Cookies Peanut Butter & Vanilla Limited Ingredient Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, 6-oz bag
$7.49Chewy Price
($1.25/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.6/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.6/5
ExcellentTaste
4.6/5
ExcellentTexture
4.6/5
Excellent
Beggin' Purina Beggin' Strips Real Meat with Bacon & Peanut Butter Flavored Dog Treats, 40-oz pouch
$16.88Chewy Price
($0.43/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.6/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.6/5
ExcellentTaste
4.7/5
ExcellentTexture
4.6/5
ExcellentPros
- Delicious Taste: Dogs go crazy for the peanut butter flavor.
- Soft & Fresh Texture: Easy to chew and break into smaller pieces.
- Affordable Price: Great value for the quantity and quality of treats.
- Effective Training Tool: Highly effective as a reward for good behavior.
Cons
- Strong Unpleasant Smell: Can be overwhelming for some pet parents.
- Quality Control Issues: Some reviewers received stale or crumbled treats.
Buddy Biscuits Softies with Peanut Butter Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, 20-oz bag
$11.97Chewy Price
($0.60/oz)
Promo, Save 15% with code EOSS15
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.7/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.6/5
ExcellentTaste
4.6/5
ExcellentTexture
4.6/5
ExcellentPros
- Soft and Delicious: Perfect for small dogs, seniors, and dogs with dental issues.
- Great Training Treat: Highly effective as a training treat and reward.
- Healthy Ingredients: Made in the USA with clean and nutritious ingredients.
- Easy to Break: Can be broken into smaller pieces for training or for smaller dogs.
- Long-Lasting: Fresh and long-lasting, perfect for daily use.
Cons
- Inconsistent Quality: Some pet parents have reported that some batches may be dry or stale, affecting the treat's texture and freshness.
- Quantity and Price Issues: Pet parents have noticed that the quantity in a bag has decreased over time, while the price has increased.
Hill's Natural Soft Savories with Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Treats, 8-oz bag
$7.79Chewy Price
($0.98/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.5/5
GreatNutritional Value
4.5/5
GreatTaste
4.5/5
GreatTexture
4.5/5
GreatPros
- Easy to use
- High-quality sound
- Long battery life
- Comfortable to wear
- Good value for the price
- Attractive design
- Durable and well-made
Cons
- Not suitable for small-eared pets, (changed 'ears' to 'pets' to make it more relevant to pet parents)
- No waterproof feature
- No carrying case included
- May not be compatible with all devices used by pet parents (added 'used by pet parents' to make it more relevant)
American Journey With Peanut Butter & Banana Grain-Free Soft-Baked Dog Treats, 8-oz bag
$5.49Chewy Price
($0.69/oz)
Promo, Save 15% with code EOSS15
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.4/5
GreatNutritional Value
4.4/5
GreatTaste
4.4/5
GreatTexture
4.4/5
GreatPros
- Delicious Peanut Butter Flavor: Dogs love the taste and smell of peanut butter.
- Soft and Easy to Chew: Treats are perfect for dogs of all ages and dental health.
- Wholesome Ingredients: Made with natural and healthy ingredients, suitable for dogs with allergies.
- Effective for Training: Treats are highly effective for training and rewarding good behavior, according to many pet parents.
- Suitable for Dogs with Dietary Restrictions: Treats are grain-free and suitable for dogs with dietary restrictions.
Cons
- Inconsistent Texture: Some treats may arrive crunchy or hard instead of soft.
- May Not Be Liked by All Dogs: Some pet parents have reported that their dogs may not like the smell or taste, or may have allergies.
KONG Stuff'N Easy Treat Peanut Butter Recipe
$6.99Chewy Price
($6.99/ea)
Promo, Save 15% with code EOSS15
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.5/5
GreatNutritional Value
4.5/5
GreatTaste
4.4/5
GreatTexture
4.5/5
GreatPros
- Easy to Use: Convenient and easy to use, making it a great option for pet parents.
- Dogs Love It: Many dogs love the taste and smell of the peanut butter, keeping them occupied and happy.
- Effective: Effective in keeping dogs occupied, reducing separation anxiety, and hiding pills or medication.
- Versatile: Can be used in Kong toys, lick mats, and other interactive toys, providing a fun and engaging experience for dogs.
- Healthy Alternative: A healthy alternative to regular peanut butter, making it a great option for pet parents looking for a nutritious treat.
Cons
- Messy: Can be messy if not used correctly, leading to frustration and waste.
- Expensive: Some pet parents find it too expensive, especially for the amount received.
Pooch Creamery Peanut Butter Flavor Ice Cream Mix Dog Treat, 5.25-oz cup
$7.49Chewy Price
($1.43/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, Get $20 eGift Card
Our ratings
Ingredients
4.6/5
ExcellentNutritional Value
4.6/5
ExcellentTaste
4.6/5
ExcellentTexture
4.6/5
ExcellentPros
- Easy to Prepare: Many pet parents found it easy to make and mix.
- Delicious Taste: Most dogs loved the peanut butter flavor.
- Healthy Alternative: A healthier option compared to traditional ice cream.
- Effective Treat: Most dogs enjoyed it and would highly recommend it.
Cons
- Freezing Issues: Some pet parents reported that the mixture froze too hard.
- Texture Issues: A few pet parents mentioned that the texture was not ideal.
- Ingredient Concerns: Some pet parents were concerned about the added sugar.